Did medieval knights get PTSD?

Yes, medieval knights did get Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). There are records from the Middle Ages that describe psychological symptoms such as intrusive thoughts, flashbacks, nightmares and severe depression experienced by returning soldiers after their battles. The emotional distress they experienced was often seen as a sign of moral weakness and piety rather than an illness or disorder. Much of this emotional trauma went unrecognized and untreated at the time, making it difficult for modern day physicians to diagnose cases retrospectively.

Today’s medical experts believe that PTSD is caused by a combination of physical and psychological factors during times of extreme stress. Symptoms include dissociation (becoming detached from reality), increased arousal levels (hyperactivity) and avoidance behaviors (avoiding people or places related to the traumatic event). During the Middle Ages these symptoms would have been interpreted differently; instead many victims were assumed to be afflicted with ‘demonic possession’ or ‘witchcraft’- further limiting treatment options available at the time.

Though not widely recognized or understood in medieval times, evidence suggests that PTSD may have been present among returning knights due to high levels of stress associated with battle experiences. Symptoms such as irritability, anxiety, fearfulness and sleep disturbances could all have been related to exposure on a battlefield situation which could then manifest into full blown post-traumatic reactions if left untreated over extended periods of time.

The Psychological Toll of Battle

While physical trauma was undoubtedly the most visible effect of battle on medieval knights, psychological tolls were equally destructive. All too often, returning warriors were afflicted with emotional and mental distress as a result of their involvement in war. This included intense feelings of anxiety, helplessness and isolation, paranoia and flashbacks to memories of death and destruction experienced during warfare. In some cases, traumatic memories became so overwhelming that they interfered with daily life activities such as eating or sleeping. Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is estimated to have affected up to 20% of medieval knights who engaged in combat regularly.

The psychological scars left by warfare had far reaching consequences for many soldiers long after the conflict had ceased. Emotional turmoil wrought by battle created an environment where veterans found it difficult to reconnect with civilian life, feeling disconnected from friends and family due to battles they had faced alone. Those grappling with PTSD could find themselves overwhelmed by familiar locations or environments that triggered painful memories which would then unleash severe bouts of depression or guilt associated with past traumas experienced in combat zones.

Social stigmas surrounding mental health issues further complicated matters for those suffering from PTSD; many felt ashamed about their condition for fear of being judged negatively by friends and family members or dismissed entirely from military service if word got out about their internal struggles. As a result, many individuals chose not to seek help even though treatment was available; this ultimately worsened symptoms until eventually leading to disabling circumstances where recovery seemed impossible without specialist intervention.

Identifying Symptoms of PTSD in Medieval Times

Diagnosing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) in medieval times is difficult because of the lack of understanding about mental illness during that time period. Historians, however, have identified various signs and behaviors indicating that PTSD existed in the Middle Ages.

The most typical symptom associated with PTSD is recurring nightmares or flashbacks, which generally feature vivid and upsetting images from a past event. Reports have shown these symptoms were described by knights who had served in battle. The knight Jean de Wavrin reported a dream he had years after his last military experience where he was “tormented by evil dreams.” Such detailed accounts offer evidence of post-war trauma experienced by medieval soldiers who often faced long periods away from home while fighting against enemies they could not understand.

In addition to recurring nightmares and flashbacks, avoidance of situations or locations reminiscent of traumatic events is another common indicator of PTSD today. In the Middle Ages, individuals exposed to violence sought solace in religious ceremony as a means to cope with guilt and distress caused by war atrocities. Knights turned to spiritual guidance from priests and monks for comfort, guidance and advice. Such behavior suggests an element of avoidance that indicates symptoms akin to those seen in current cases of PTSD sufferers today. Other symptoms exhibited by knights exhibiting signs similar to modern day patients suffering from PTSD include feelings of anxiety or unease when presented with reminders or memories related to traumatic events; difficulty sleeping; increased aggression or irritability; forgetfulness; social isolation; alcoholism; low moods; heightened startle responses amongst other physical symptoms such as headaches and nausea.

Historical Accounts of Traumatized Knights

As times have changed, so have our understanding of mental health. We now understand that Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) can affect people long after a traumatic event has occurred. Although we have only been aware of it for the past few decades, there is evidence to suggest that medieval knights may also have suffered from this disorder.

The oldest documented account of a knight who was traumatized by war dates back to 1145 AD when Geoffrey de Charny wrote about a certain Frenchman whose abilities were forever diminished due to witnessing too many wars and tragedies. This individual, known as Galon of England, found himself haunted with mental distress which made it difficult for him to even hold his sword or shield properly in battle – something unheard of for a seasoned warrior such as himself.

Moreover, John Mandeville’s book ‘Travels’ is littered with stories about warriors who were plagued with terror and anguish as a result of their experiences during the crusades and other battles throughout Europe and Asia Minor. His accounts detail how some warriors “went mad” while others simply stopped fighting altogether out of fear – further evidence that PTSD-like symptoms were indeed present in at least some medieval knights.

It is unclear just how widespread cases like these truly were but they do provide us with valuable insight into the effects warfare had on individuals during those tumultuous centuries.

Coping Mechanisms Used by Knights

The life of a knight during the Middle Ages was one of rigor and danger. These brave men, often from noble families, had to face warfare head-on and endure immense amounts of physical strain in battle. With such intense circumstances and dangerous encounters, it’s no wonder that many knights experienced Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Though there were no formal treatments for PTSD at this time, these knights were able to use certain strategies as coping mechanisms for the horrors of war.

The most common approach was maintaining an active lifestyle. Knights would focus their energies on pursuing tasks like hunting or jousting which helped them manage post-war stress and distract their minds from unpleasant memories of combat. They could practice chivalric activities including respect towards women and loyalty to other knights which served to reinforce both social values and team cohesion among members of warrior groups.

Though not ideal or effective today by modern medical standards, prayer was another frequent route taken by warriors who had seen conflict up close. Writing prayers such as Psalm 21 allowed them to fully express their emotions while seeking solace in God’s love amidst hard times. Reflection upon religious teachings seemed to help some knights find inner peace in spite of extreme suffering caused by traumatic experiences on the battlefields across Europe centuries ago.

Stigma Surrounding Mental Health in the Middle Ages

During the Middle Ages, there was a strong stigma surrounding mental health. Mental illness was seen as an evil or demonic curse and those who experienced it were treated as outcasts in society. This meant that medieval knights suffering from psychological trauma after battle would be unlikely to seek help for their condition, leading to many suffering in silence with untreated Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Not only were people wary of seeking aid due to the fear of being seen as “cursed”, but even if they did manage to overcome this, limited resources available at the time made it difficult for individuals to receive effective treatment.

Moreover, social expectations placed on men during this period likely exacerbated these issues. The concept of “machismo” encouraged men–including knights–to have a stoic exterior, suppress emotions and prove their masculinity through feats of physical strength or combat prowess. As such, any sign of weakness such as mental health struggles could have been viewed by other knights as shameful and embarrassing. Consequently, feelings of shame associated with PTSD might have kept medieval warriors from admitting their difficulties and prevented them from getting much needed help or support during trying times.

It is possible that because so few historical records document cases of PTSD among medieval soldiers, historians may underestimate its true prevalence among this population group. In light of the clear stigma around mental health conditions present throughout history until modern times – which only further complicates our understanding – more research should be conducted in order to better understand how common psychological trauma truly was among military personnel during the Middle Ages.

Comparisons with Modern Understanding of PTSD

The modern understanding of Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is that it can result from a wide range of traumatic experiences. Traumas such as combat, physical assault, and childhood abuse are known to cause PTSD. However, the study of Medieval knights offers insight into how post-combat trauma has been experienced throughout history.

Today we recognize that not all trauma survivors develop symptoms and signs of PTSD but in some cases psychological issues can linger long after the initial event. During Medieval times, events such as battle were seen as part and parcel with the life of a knight, so recognition of psychological struggles was largely ignored or simply written off as weakness. This lack of recognition only compounded their mental burden and prevented any meaningful attempts at resolution or healing to take place until much later in life when soldiers returned home from battle.

In this context there are many similarities between medieval knights’ experience and our contemporary understanding; however there remain fundamental differences too due to the cultural norms prevailing during different eras. For instance today combat veterans will receive support tailored specifically for them whereas Medieval warriors had no such provisions available to them – leading to far fewer chances for recovery compared with now where numerous treatments exist ranging from psychotherapy to medication regimes specifically designed for individuals living with PTSD.

Lessons Learned for Current and Future Military Personnel

The bravery and strength of knights in medieval times has been a source of admiration and respect. Despite the heroics involved, the consequences of these engagements often resulted in psychological trauma for soldiers. Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is an ever present reality for those who serve their countries now and into the future. Studying examples from yesteryear can help inform preventative strategies to better address PTSD among today’s military personnel.

Just as modern day soldiers process memories from encounters on the battlefield, so too did their predecessors such as knights during medieval times. The prolonged bloodshed combined with social destabilisation created an environment where PTSD was likely unavoidable no matter how strong one’s convictions were or mental health was prior to battle. Mental distress due to events on the battleground resulted in paranoia, anger outbursts, difficulty sleeping, and various other symptoms that are still being diagnosed today hundreds of years later among current servicemen and women across multiple continents.

On a brighter note though, incorporating lessons learned from history into post-conflict rehabilitation programs can better prepare those who have survived warzones with valuable coping skills before they reintegrate back into society at large or take part in similar engagement scenarios again down the line. Today’s technology provides more resources than ever before to mental health professionals who provide direct services for men and women returning home from combat zones thereby allowing us to learn from past experiences without making all same mistakes twice over when it comes to PTSD treatment outcomes.

About the author.
Jay Roberts is the founder of the Debox Method and after nearly 10 years and hundreds of sessions, an expert in the art of emotional release to remove the negative effects of trauma. Through his book, courses, coaching, and talks Jay’s goal is to teach as many people as he can the power of the Debox Method. 

© Debox 2022