Is PTSD and shell shock the same?

No, PTSD and Shell Shock are not the same. PTSD stands for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, a mental health condition that can develop after a person is exposed to one or more traumatic events such as military combat, natural disasters, assault or other violence. Symptoms can include flashbacks, nightmares, intrusive thoughts and hypervigilance.

Shell Shock is an old term used to describe what is now known as PTSD in World War I veterans; however its definition has changed over time. The symptoms of shell shock were similar to those of today’s PTSD: anxiety, depression, insomnia and emotional numbness. It was believed that these symptoms could be caused by witnessing horrific events such as warfare and extreme violence during war times.

Today’s understanding of PTSD has grown significantly since the original description of shell shock with advancements in medicine leading to more accurate diagnosis and effective treatments available to those who experience it. While the two may share some characteristics there are many differences between them and should not be confused with one another.

Differences between PTSD and Shell Shock

As people become more familiar with the effects of war, the terms PTSD and shell shock have been used interchangeably to describe a form of mental trauma. However, there are distinctions that should be made between the two conditions.

Although both PTSD and shell shock are mental health conditions that stem from extreme or life-threatening experiences, they differ in key ways. For instance, PTSD is a psychological reaction to such events while shell shock is defined as an emotional response. This means that PTSD may take longer to treat because it’s rooted in neurology and brain chemistry; however, symptoms of shell shock can dissipate over time if the person receives timely support from family and friends.

Sufferers of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder often experience flashbacks which prompt memories of traumatic events for them to relive again and again throughout their lifetime; on the other hand, those with shell shock only experience temporary reactions due to their psychological state at the moment when faced with distressing stimuli such as loud noises. Therefore, prolonged exposure to these triggers can increase a person’s vulnerability towards developing lasting PTSD symptoms if not addressed properly.

Common Symptoms of PTSD

Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is an anxiety disorder triggered by a traumatic event such as military combat, natural disasters, violent assault or other extreme experiences. It is not the same as shell shock which dates back to World War I and was used to describe symptoms of battle fatigue in war veterans. PTSD can develop from any intense and stressful experience whether it be physical or emotional, whereas shell shock primarily affects soldiers involved in active combat.

Common symptoms of PTSD include nightmares, flashbacks, hypervigilance, jumpiness, difficulty sleeping or concentrating and severe depression that may last for weeks on end. Other emotional reactions associated with post-traumatic stress include feeling isolated from society, having persistent fears about safety and lacking trust in those around you. An individual suffering from PTSD may also feel guilt or shame due to their inability to control the situation when the trauma occurred. To help alleviate these difficult emotions they often resort to alcohol or drug abuse as a coping mechanism.

In terms of treatment options for PTSD sufferers there are several psychotherapeutic approaches available such as cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), group therapy and eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR). Medication may be prescribed if deemed necessary by a medical professional but typically should only be used alongside psychotherapy instead of on its own. Self-care is extremely important when living with post-traumatic stress so activities like yoga, breathing exercises and journaling are highly recommended.

History of Shell Shock Diagnosis

Throughout history, people have experienced a variety of emotional and physical reactions to the trauma of war. In World War I, the concept of shell shock was used to describe some of these responses. While shell shock is related to Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), there are significant differences in diagnosis and treatment options.

The phrase ‘shell shock’ first appeared in 1915 in the British Medical Journal. At the time it referred to symptoms which included cognitive impairments, neurasthenia and psychological disturbances such as hysterical paralysis or fits caused by exposure to enemy fire and warfare stressors. During WWI mental health services were significantly underdeveloped so many veterans did not receive an accurate diagnosis or proper care for their distress.

In WW2 shell shock was redefined from a strictly medical issue with observable symptoms such as tremors, paralysis and blindness into one that was accepted as being largely psychogenic in origin – connected with traumatic experiences during battle resulting from sudden surprises like explosions or gunfire. Thus soldiers could be diagnosed based on changes in behavior rather than physical symptoms alone though those too were still taken into account when making assessments of individual cases. However recognition of this new condition remained poor both within civilian life after service discharge as well military circles where attitudes towards psychological distress continued to be biased against mentally ill servicemen despite its growing acceptance amongst psychiatric professionals outside the forces establishment.

Medical Treatments for Both Conditions

When it comes to treating Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and shell shock, there are similarities in the medical approaches used. Both involve psychological therapy to help individuals cope with their experiences and memories of a traumatic event. However, there are also differences when it comes to medical treatments for PTSD and shell shock.

The most common type of treatment for PTSD is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). CBT involves talking about the traumatic event(s) with a therapist and learning how to process thoughts, feelings, and behaviors related to these events. Through this method, individuals can learn how to regulate their emotions better and manage triggers that may lead them back into negative thinking or reactions from the traumatic incident(s).

For shell shock sufferers, one form of treatment is EMDR or Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing. This psychotherapeutic approach helps those suffering from both PTSD and shell shock by using bilateral stimulation techniques like eye movements or auditory tones while recalling painful events that have occurred in the past. The aim of this treatment is to reduce distress caused by these memories so they become easier to manage over time. Other forms of therapy including Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), Prolonged Exposure Therapy (PE), Trauma Focused-Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (TF-CBT) as well as other types cognitive-behavioral therapies can be employed depending on individual needs.

Medications such as SSRIs may also be prescribed for both conditions depending on each patient’s specific symptoms. While medications can provide short term relief for some patients with PTSD or shell shock, long term use has not been shown to be particularly effective so doctors often recommend only taking them under close supervision when needed instead of relying solely on pharmacological interventions over long periods of time.

Trauma as a Common Cause

Trauma is a major cause of PTSD and shell shock, but they are distinct in their symptomology. PTSD typically manifests as reliving events through flashbacks or dreams, while shell shock is marked by more external psychological symptoms such as difficulty concentrating and rapid mood swings. Both disorders can be extremely debilitating; however, it is important to distinguish between them to ensure proper treatment.

Studies have shown that the majority of cases for both PTSD and shell shock stem from experiencing or witnessing extreme trauma or violence either in wartime or during civilian life. Experiences like military combat, physical abuse, sexual assault, natural disasters, terrorist attacks and car accidents can all cause patients to develop PTSD or shell shock depending on their individual experience and physiological makeup.

Due to the shared etiology of these two mental illnesses, experts agree that many treatments used for one disorder may also be beneficial for the other. While there are some differences in terms of management strategies – such as cognitive-behavioral therapy being considered most effective for treating post-traumatic stress syndrome – overall there has been great progress in research into therapeutic interventions which could assist individuals suffering from either condition.

Myths Surrounding Shell Shock and PTSD

Despite a certain level of overlap between post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and shell shock, there are several significant differences that make them distinct from one another. This has given rise to various myths and misconceptions surrounding these conditions, with many people believing that PTSD and shell shock are effectively the same thing.

The two conditions can share symptoms such as flashbacks, avoidance of stimuli associated with traumatic events, sleeping problems, poor concentration, depression or anxiety. But a key distinction is that while PTSD typically occurs after single traumatic event in an otherwise healthy individual, shell shock is most commonly seen in soldiers returning from extended periods of combat. As such it often includes more complex physical manifestations like trembling or speech impediments which may be absent in PTSD sufferers.

An additional factor setting the two mental health issues apart is the fact that there are multiple causative factors contributing to each condition. While PTSD arises mostly due to exposure to trauma – either through direct personal experience or witnessing something particularly distressing – shell shock can have both psychological and physiological components. For example soldiers facing extreme danger on a regular basis will find their bodies preparing for fight-or-flight mode via increased adrenaline production even when not consciously aware of any danger present; this reaction combined with psychological repercussions may lead to serious long-term consequences if left untreated.

The Importance of Accurate Diagnosis and Treatment

Accurate diagnosis and treatment of PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder) and shell shock is key to patient care. Both conditions stem from a person experiencing psychological trauma in one form or another, which can vary greatly from person to person. While the overall symptoms may appear similar, distinguishing between the two disorders is essential for prescribing appropriate treatments.

Specially trained medical professionals should assess each individual’s condition and mental health history before determining whether PTSD or shell shock is present. In some cases, both conditions may be present simultaneously with different levels of severity, requiring an experienced doctor to differentiate between the two diagnoses. Depending on the specific case, treating only one without addressing the other could create new issues while diminishing current symptoms.

Misunderstanding these ailments can lead to misdiagnosis and mistreatment if left unchecked, making it hard for those affected to make meaningful strides towards recovery. An accurate diagnosis through comprehensive assessment will allow doctors to prescribe medications and other interventions that are suited specifically for either PTSD or shell shock – depending on the evaluation – as opposed to just generic treatments designed for vague symptoms common among them both. This means better results long term since proper treatment plans target underlying causes instead of surface level effects which tend not lead to lasting healing.

About the author.
Jay Roberts is the founder of the Debox Method and after nearly 10 years and hundreds of sessions, an expert in the art of emotional release to remove the negative effects of trauma. Through his book, courses, coaching, and talks Jay’s goal is to teach as many people as he can the power of the Debox Method. 

© Debox 2022